The Donors You Win on Giving Tuesday and Lose by March

The Goodness Report, November 2026: Keeping GivingTuesday donors, building a global community for cystinosis families and celebrating five PRism Awards

GivingTuesday is one of the best days of the year for nonprofits to gain new supporters. Research from the Blackbaud Institute and GivingTuesday shows that 65% of GivingTuesday donors give again the following year, compared with 52% of all donors. Roughly one in six GivingTuesday donors is giving to that organization for the first time.

Many nonprofits plan for months to win these donors but have no plan for how to keep them. At Idea Hall, we believe the gift is the start of the relationship. A donor who hears nothing meaningful until a spring appeal has little reason to give again. Here is how to make the most of the months that follow.

The first 48 hours: make the thank-you count

The first message after a gift sets the tone for everything that follows.

Thank donors quickly and personally.
Send a thank-you within a day or two, signed by a real person. Use the donor’s name and reference the campaign they supported.
Treat first-time donors differently.
Someone giving to your organization for the first time needs an introduction to who you are and why your work matters. A long-time supporter does not.
Start a welcome series.
Follow the thank-you with a planned sequence of three or four messages that introduces your mission, shares a story and invites the donor to stay involved.

The first 30 days: show the impact

The weeks after GivingTuesday are when donors decide whether their gift made a difference.

Show what each gift delivers.
Tell donors what their contribution made possible. For example, a food bank might explain that a $20 gift provides five meals for a neighbor in need.
Share stories from the people you serve.
A 30-second video featuring someone your organization has helped makes the impact real.

Through March: stay in touch between asks

This is the period when most organizations go quiet, and it is where donors are lost.

Invite donors to take part.
Volunteer opportunities, events and mentoring programs give supporters a role in the mission beyond their gift.
Ask before you ask again.
Before your next appeal, send a short survey asking donors what they want to hear about, such as events, volunteer opportunities or success stories. Then tailor your communication to their answers.

Consistent follow-up depends on a clear internal process. Segment your donor lists by gift size, giving frequency and whether donors are new to your organization, because a first-time $25 donor and a returning $1,000 donor need different messages. Then decide who owns each step of the plan and put the dates on the calendar before GivingTuesday arrives.

Where to start

Keeping GivingTuesday donors begins with understanding where your current process is strong and where supporters are slipping away. Idea Hall’s Donor Funnel Report is a five-minute assessment that grades each stage of your donor funnel and shows where to focus first. It is the first step in Compound Giving, Idea Hall’s approach to donor retention and lifecycle. Just as interest compounds over time, every donor you keep builds on the last, and the program helps nonprofits put that growth to work.

GivingTuesday wins new donors. A thoughtful plan for the months that follow is what keeps them.

To talk through your plan, connect with us.

Also in this issue

You Are Not Alone: Building a Global Community for Cystinosis Research Foundation

Staying connected between asks is what keeps supporters close to a mission. For the Cystinosis Research Foundation, that connection is the mission itself. Cystinosis is so rare that many patients and families spend years searching for reliable information and for others who understand their experience. Idea Hall partnered with CRF to turn its Facebook and Instagram channels into a year-round community for patients, caregivers, researchers, advocates and donors around the world.

Our research showed that CRF’s audience wanted two things: clear updates on research and treatment, and authentic stories from people living with cystinosis. We built the program around both. We translated complex studies into plain language for families who follow every advancement, and shared personal stories that put real faces behind the disease.

Animated Instagram carousel from the Cystinosis Research Foundation, A Quick Guide to Understanding Cystinosis, swiping through slides on who it affects, whether there is a cure and how to advocate, share and support

The results exceeded every goal. Instagram impressions grew 250% and Facebook impressions grew 35.5% year over year. Engagement rates reached 12.65% on Facebook and 10.14% on Instagram, well above nonprofit averages of 1.8% and 4.4%. Followers grew more than 55% on both platforms, and post shares more than doubled.

The program also earned a 2026 PRism Award for Social Media.


Also in this issue

Idea Hall wins five PRSA Los Angeles PRism Awards

CRF’s program was one of five Idea Hall campaigns honored at the 62nd Annual PRism Awards, presented by PRSA Los Angeles on October 28. The PRism Awards are the region’s premier program recognizing excellence in public relations and communications. This year’s wins span public relations, digital marketing, graphic design, public affairs and social media.

Five 2026 PRSA Los Angeles PRism Award trophies engraved for Idea Hall, displayed together

Orangewood Foundation, “More Than a Name.”
Orange County’s biggest giving day offered Orangewood Foundation a chance to reach new supporters. Our earned media campaign repositioned the organization and showed the community the full scope of its work.

Second Harvest Food Bank of Orange County, “From Search to Support.”
Second Harvest is eligible for free advertising through the Google Ad Grants program. We turned that grant into a digital campaign that connected people searching for ways to help with meaningful opportunities to support the food bank.

UC Irvine, “60th Anniversary Poster Series.”
To mark UC Irvine’s 60th anniversary, we created a series of posters celebrating six decades of impact. The series brings the university’s history and achievements to life through original design.

Be Well OC, “Cutting Through Red Tape.”
Access to mental health care remains a challenge for many Orange County residents. Our public affairs campaign mobilized community members to advocate for improved access to care.

Cystinosis Research Foundation, “You Are Not Alone.”
Our social media program, featured above, built a global community for families affected by cystinosis.

We are grateful to PRSA Los Angeles for the recognition and to our clients for trusting us with work that matters to their communities.